From #SHRM13 – The Men of HR

SHRMKickball

 

Jeff Pon, Chief Human Resource Officer for SHRM, is a man of HR.

I had the pleasure of re-connecting with him on Sunday at SHRM13, and we had an interesting discussion about the demographics of SHRM members. According to Jeff, SHRM has large chunks of HR practitioners – those in their first 10 years of practice and those at the highest job classifications – who are noticeably absent from SHRM membership.

During the course of our discussion, Jeff also mentioned that 81% of attendees at the conference were women, reflecting the gender make-up of the profession.

But everyone knows – and comments – on the fact that HR is a female dominated profession, so his remarks didn’t surprise me at all. It wasn’t until a little later, reflecting on our conversation, that the proverbial lightbulb flashed on in my head:

I know lots more men in HR than I should, given the statistical domination of women in the space.

And the more I thought, the more I realized that the number of my professional HR contacts was almost evenly split between men and women. How could that be?

It didn’t take me long to figure out the reason: bloggers and SHRM volunteers.

Look at the picture above of the SHRM bloggers who played kickball for charity during the conference. Of those 25 people, 13 are men. Now you might argue that the numbers are a little bit skewed because the teams were designed to be split evenly between men and women. That misses the point that there was an equal number of men available to play, when logic seems to demand that the HR bloggers should be about 80% female.

But there is a pretty even split of men to women among HR bloggers, as you can see by looking at this more casual picture of SHRM bloggers working, and taken before I even had my discussion with Jeff Pon.

SHRM13BloggerLounge

 

I also know that membership in the two SHRM local affiliates I belong to is predominately women, running close to the expected 80-20 split. But the working volunteers and leaders who do more than pay dues (run committees, serve as board directors, etc.) has a much higher percentage of men.

The question that springs to my mind – as usual – is WHY?

When I asked some of my fellow bloggers this question, they thought it was because women were working practitioners with less time to be involved. I disagree with this, because a lot of the men – especially the active SHRM volunteers – are working practitioners, too.

My theory is that women tend to shy away from professional opportunities and development, because “cultural messages undermine their leadership”, as argued most recently by Sheryl Sandberg and her Lean In manifesto. So the “extra” work of blogging or volunteer leadership is dismissed by a large percentage of the female HR pros.

And while I love the conversations and connections I have with these smart and savvy men of HR who blog and those who work so tirelessly for SHRM and its affiliates,  I am a little dismayed that more women aren’t represented, given the larger number of working HR pros who are female.

What’s your theory?

 

 

 

 

 

Share

3 thoughts on “From #SHRM13 – The Men of HR”

  1. Hi, Joan. My personal story is that I am a HR practitioner and Mom first, volunteer second. So I go to work early and work through lunch so that I can rush out of work to get my kids to practice, finish homework, make dinner, do laundry and organize family life. My husband is very involved, but it’s just not the same for him. I want to spend every minute that I can with my kids until they don’t want me around. I also love working in HR. I was more involved in my SHRM chapter and blogged a little bit when my kids were little and didn’t have outside activities. There will be plenty of time to volunteer again when they are too cool for me.

  2. Thanks for weighing in, Bonita. If your comments are indicative of the feelings of the general women in HR population, then the division is truly a cultural issue.

    I hope a couple of the guys like Ben Eubanks or Matt Stollak, who both work full time jobs and are active parents, will respond to this. It would be nice to have a guy’s perspective on your comment.

    Thanks again!

  3. I don’t know if there is a real answer to the question. I don’t agree with the assumption that Dads are less engaged parents. I spent just as much time with my children, as they grew up, as did my wife.

    I think women are a little less comfortable simply putting themselves out there as men are (because there are a lot of creepy guys out here).

    Let see what the othe Men of HR have to say.

Comments are closed.